Classical (Baumgarten) and Non-Classical (Kant) Scientific Rationality as the Foundation of the Interconnection between Scientific and Artistic Knowlendge
Introduction. In Kant’s philosophical system, the aesthetic power of judgment – which many authors associate with artistic cognition – lacks epistemological meaning. This raises the question of whether artistic cognition and its connection with scientific cognition can be meaningfully discussed within Kant’s philosophy. The aim of this article is to resolve this problem by examining the intellectual relationship between I. Kant and A. Baumgarten, who exerted a significant influence on him. The relevance of turning to Baumgarten’s legacy is determined by the fact that the last two decades have seen the first translations of his Metaphysics into English and his Aesthetics into Russian. Methodology and sources. The connection between scientific and artistic cognition is explored within the methodology of historical epistemology, which allows us to address current issues in the philosophy of science by examining the historical and philosophical aspects of the formation of scientific method. In analyzing the views of A. Baumgarten and I. Kant, the study employs the classification of types of scientific rationality proposed by V.S. Stepin, whose application to the connection between scientific and artistic cognition was suggested by S.Ya. Nevkrytaya. The sources include texts by Baumgarten and Kant, as well as works by scholars who have reflected on this problem. Results and discussion. The article examines the philosophical understanding of the connection between scientific and artistic cognition through a comparison of human sensory cognition and the idea of the divine intellect in A. Baumgarten’s thought. For I. Kant, who rejects the idea of God as the basis for comparing the two types of cognition, the meaning of artistic cognition is narrowed down to the aesthetic power of judgment. Conclusion. It is concluded that Baumgarten’s reflection on the connection between the two types of cognition corresponds to the position of classical scientific rationality, while Kant’s corresponds to non-classical scientific rationality.
Authors: Denis A. Tekhov
Direction: Philosophy
Keywords: Kant, Baumgarten, scientific cognition, artistic cognition, sensory cognition, scientific rationality, aesthetic judgment
View full article